The Public Good and the Lottery

The lottery is a popular form of gambling in which people buy tickets to win prizes, including money and goods. It is the most popular form of gambling in the United States, with Americans spending upwards of $100 billion on tickets in 2021. It is a ubiquitous activity, with state governments advertising lotteries on television and in newspapers, and convenience stores selling scratch-off tickets. Lottery profits are a substantial source of revenue for many state governments, and the government at all levels promotes it as a way to fund public services without raising taxes. However, the lottery also profits from a large segment of the population that is vulnerable to addictive gambling and other problems.

The casting of lots for decisions and the determination of fates has a long history, dating back to the earliest recorded lotteries organized by Augustus Caesar to raise funds for public works projects in Rome, and to distribute gifts such as dinnerware to participants in Saturnalian festivities. The first publicly-sold lotteries that offered tickets with prize money of unequal value were probably introduced in the Low Countries in the 15th century, and records show that a number of towns held lotteries to raise funds for town fortifications and for the poor.

Modern state lotteries typically follow similar patterns: the legislature establishes a monopoly; a public agency or corporation is established to manage it; the operation begins with a modest number of relatively simple games; and, due to the constant pressure for additional revenues, the lottery progressively expands its product line, adding new games and raising prices, in order to increase revenues. Lottery revenue increases are usually accompanied by a steady decrease in state expenditures, and the resulting budget deficits are a frequent subject of political debate and controversy.

The problem is that there is little evidence that the popularity of the lottery is related to the state’s actual fiscal health, or even its general economic health; and the underlying dynamic seems to be more one of political expediency than one of sound public policy. Nonetheless, it appears that the success of a lottery depends on the degree to which its proceeds are perceived as benefiting a particular public good, such as education. This argument is a powerful one, particularly in an era of anti-tax sentiment and increased competition for state dollars. It has influenced the development of state lotteries in all fifty states, and it is a key factor in sustaining their broad public support.